[RL-Diss] First and Second Language Listening Comprehension and RLS Effects

Investigating Factors Affecting Listening Comprehension in Different Language Listeners

Recruiting
18 years - 30 years
All
Phase N/A
1 Location

Brief description of study.

The purpose of this study is to examine the factors that contribute to greater or less success in listening comprehension for first and second language listeners. We are particularly interested in the effect of different speakers, and of your memory span on comprehension. The goal is to understand how people listen to lectures in real university classes.

Detailed description of study

In 2009, Kang and Rubin had American undergraduates listen to academic lectures and provided pictures and personal information of the speakers. Some students were told they were listening to a Chinese speaker, while others were told that they were listening to a white American speaker. Students who believed they listened to the Chinese speaker performed worse on listening comprehension tasks and reported that the speaker was accented, even though the audio files were identical and from a separate native speaker. The listeners in the study were graded on their performance; they were not sabotaging their own comprehension. Rather, listener expectations affected comprehension in ways beyond their conscious control. In contrast to ?Linguistic Stereotyping? in which listeners make judgments about speakers? origin, personality, or other traits based on their accent, Kang and Rubin called this observed effect ?Reverse Linguistic Stereotyping? (RLS). RLS is ?reversed? in the sense that listeners attribute an accent to a speaker based on the information about the speaker?s origin.
RLS effects have been replicated in several studies since then, but there has been heated debate concerning why these effects exist, or to what extent they are generalized to other settings. While Kang argues that the effects are straightforwardly caused by negative bias and lowered attention and effort, McGowan and others suggest that the effects occur because of a mismatch between people's expectations for accented speech and the actual audio signal. Lev-Ari and others, meanwhile, argue that it is people's tendency to think flexibly and remain agnostic on details and nuances when listening to non-native speakers that explains the phenomenon. She argues this in part by showing that people with higher working memory, which is normally associated with better performance on listening tests, was actually harmful in certain listening tasks with non-native speakers because people were more willing and able to entertain options about what the speaker might have meant, rather than simply listening to the literal meaning of the words.
These competing hypotheses were all based on very disparate types of tasks, with different participant groups and analyses, however. This study uses 8 experimental texts in different conditions, with "matched" and "mismatched" accent expectations, and with questions that specifically target nuances and details as well as others that target main ideas, in order to evaluate these three hypotheses against each other directly. Most importantly, there are three groups of listeners: white American listeners, Chinese students (who share the same background as the putative non-native speaker), and Korean students (who are also non-natives but out-group with respect to the putative non-native speaker), to examine how and whether bias and familiarity impact listening comprehension in these settings.
This study takes place in Bloomington, IN and is recruiting IU Bloomington undergraduate students.

Participants will be compensated for their participation.

Eligibility of study

You may be eligible for this study if you meet the following criteria:

  • Conditions: healthy
  • Age: 18 years - 30 years
  • Gender: All

Inclusion Criteria
Undergraduate student in the United States
No experience living abroad for more than 3 months
No history of hearing or speech disorders for which they have received speech therapy

Updated on 19 Feb 2024. Study ID: 1802120284

This study investigates how different factors affect listening comprehension in both first and second language listeners. It focuses on how the identity of the speaker and the listener's memory span influence understanding. The study aims to explore how people comprehend lectures in real university settings, considering the phenomenon of Reverse Linguistic Stereotyping (RLS), where listeners attribute an accent based on speaker background information.

Participants will listen to 8 experimental texts with varied accent expectations. They will answer questions focusing on details and main ideas to evaluate different hypotheses about listening comprehension. The study includes three groups: white American listeners, Chinese students, and Korean students, to see how bias and familiarity affect understanding.

  • Who can participate: Participants must be undergraduate students in the United States with no experience living abroad for more than 3 months. They should not have a history of hearing or speech disorders that required speech therapy.
  • Study details: Participants will listen to lectures and answer questions about them. They will be grouped based on their background to assess how different factors affect their listening comprehension.

Find a site

Message sent successfully.
We have submitted the information you provided to the research team at the location you chose. For your records, we have sent a copy of the message to your email address.
If you would like to be informed of other studies that may be of interest to you, you may sign up for Patient Notification Service.
Sign up

Send a message

Enter your contact details to connect with study team

Investigator Avatar

Primary Contact

First name*
Last name*
Email*
Phone number*
Preferred way of contact label
Race
Ethnicity
Other language

Default Content Message Here